Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin

Amid plummeting state tax collections, the Commonwealth has options

It’s a sudden economic freefall like no other. By some estimates, Massachusetts will have 473,000 COVID-induced job layoffs and furloughs by summer. Most people with jobs won’t make or spend as much in the months ahead. Almost every source of revenue on which the state relies — like income taxes, business taxes, sales taxes, gambling taxes and more — will plunge.

How far could tax collections fall? Potentially, very far — perhaps $5 billion or more below the amount lawmakers were counting on for Fiscal Year 2021. As the Commonwealth scrambles to balance the books and stabilize revenues, it should take steps to shore up revenue for the medium and long-term. The initial focus should be on eliminating tax breaks that benefit the highest-income households and profitable corporations. Our state has thrived because we invest in our people. In this crisis and its aftermath, how we tax will reflect our values more than ever.

If tax collections in the current recession follow the pattern seen in the last two recessions, we can expect tax revenue to fall off a cliff. In the first year following the start of the last two recessions (so, in Fiscal Year (FY) 2002 and FY2009), Massachusetts state tax collections dropped by 16.1 percent and 13.8 percent respectively, adjusted for inflation. In each previous downturn it took six years after the start of the recession for inflation-adjusted collections to return to their pre-recession levels. Were similar percentage drops to occur at today’s collection levels, the Commonwealth would see a loss of $4.2 billion to $4.8 billion in FY2020. Factoring in the further loss of expected tax growth during the coming fiscal year (which now seems unlikely to materialize), tax collections could fall $5.0 billion to $5.7 billion below the levels lawmakers had been expecting for FY2021.

Image for post

In its initial rounds of emergency aid, the federal government will deliver some help to the states. The Commonwealth, our municipalities, and transit authorities appear poised to receive about $4 billion in federal aid. The Commonwealth will need more federal funds to respond to the virus and provide support to people left out of federal relief programs. Massachusetts can’t stop investing in its people, especially in those who are most vulnerable.

Soon lawmakers will need to build a budget for the coming fiscal year — which begins in just three months. One option state lawmakers will not have is to run a deficit, as the federal government does. Our state Constitution prohibits borrowing to fund ongoing operations. When tax revenues fall, lawmakers must find other ways to bring the budget back into balance. One way to avoid deep cuts to essential state programs is to reconsider costly tax breaks.

We are fortunate to have $3.5 billion in our Rainy Day Fund. These resources, however, could be dwarfed by the scale of state revenue losses we may see in the months and years ahead. Recognizing this as a possible — or even a likely — scenario, we should act now to place the Commonwealth in a better financial position over the medium to longer-term. We can delay, reduce or eliminate a number of tax breaks, the benefits of which are narrowly focused on the highest-income households and large, profitable corporations — the folks that have taken the lion’s share of income gains over the last several decades. For instance, we could:

  • Eliminate, reduce the cost of, and/or delay implementation of a new state charitable deduction that otherwise would go into effect next January. The Governor recommended examining these options in his most recent budget proposal, even before the COVID crisis. Without legislative action, this new tax break will cost the Commonwealth $300 million a year, almost half of which will go to households with incomes over $1 million a year.

The next few years will be exceedingly challenging. Lawmakers will face many hard trade-offs as they attempt to address burgeoning needs with dwindling resources. With enough federal aid and prudent use of our Rainy Day Fund — along with proactive policies that increase tax collections and tax fairness — lawmakers can see us through the current crisis and set us on a path to a stronger recovery. Eliminating wasteful tax breaks should be at the center of these efforts.


Envisioning Equity Part II: Housing to Build a Just Recovery

Watch the full recap to learn the housing policy challenges existing at the national, state, regional, and local levels and to explore ways that antiracist policy choices can help build housing for a just recovery.

Read More →

Testimony for the House and Senate Ways and Means Committees, the Joint Committee on Revenue, and the Executive Office of Administration and Finance Economic Roundtable

We’re clearly in a budget crisis. Which is extremely troubling at this time, when we need real, comprehensive relief for families and individuals — so many of our neighbors, young and old, are struggling with accessing basic necessities and keeping healthy and well.

Our Commonwealth’s budget – how we raise revenue through taxes and fees, and how we spend that revenue – is the clearest picture of our shared values. Considering the revenue side picture is crucial, but the other side of the ledger is just, if not more important.

Read More →

State Borrowing is No Substitute for New Revenue in Dealing with the COVID-19 Economic Downturn

States rely on borrowing to manage their finances in good times and bad. Yet borrowing is not a substitute for raising the revenue needed for an economic recovery. Policymakers should look to raising progressive new revenues paired with limited borrowing to avoid cuts to critical public spending.

Read More →
Scroll to Top

Get news from Massachusetts Budget and Policy Center in your inbox.

Select list(s) to subscribe to

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Massachusetts Budget and Policy Center, 1 State Street, Boston, MA, 02109, You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact